TLDR: User-Generated Content (UGC) has become a staple in digital marketing, but it’s starting to feel a little, well, stale. As UGC becomes less authentic, brands need to rethink their approach to maintaining a genuine connection with their audience. This post explores how brands can regain control over their messaging while still benefiting from the power of UGC.
User-Generated Content (UGC) has had a good run. Remember when UGC felt fresh and authentic, back when a customer’s photo or video felt like an honest peek into how people used and loved your product? Yeah, those were the days. Now, it’s a bit like the party guest who overstayed their welcome—still there, but not really adding to the fun.
So, what’s happened? UGC has become predictable, and in some cases, painfully inauthentic. Everyone’s a “brand ambassador,” but the genuine enthusiasm is often missing. Brands, it’s time to take a step back and reconsider: Is UGC doing your brand justice, or is it time to shake things up?
The Problem with UGC Today: When “Authenticity” Feels Forced
UGC used to be the go-to for showing a brand’s authenticity. After all, who better to promote your product than real people using it in their everyday lives? But somewhere along the line, UGC started feeling less like spontaneous customer love and more like a marketing strategy—and a not-so-subtle one at that.
What Went Wrong?
• Over-Saturation: When everyone is doing it, it stops feeling special. UGC once felt unique and engaging because it was rare. Now, it’s everywhere, and the novelty has worn off.
• Inauthentic Content: Too many staged photos, over-scripted testimonials, and influencer partnerships that feel more transactional than genuine have made UGC lose its shine. What used to feel real now often feels rehearsed.
• Lack of Control: Relying heavily on UGC means surrendering some control over how your brand is portrayed. And let’s face it, not all UGC is created equal. Some content might not align with your brand’s image or messaging, which can dilute your brand’s impact.
UGC has become predictable and often inauthentic, which can dilute your brand’s image rather than enhance it.
Taking Back Control: Reimagining Authenticity in Brand Content
(Example: SoHo House mixing in UGC and a clean asthetic)
Brands need to pivot from relying on UGC as a crutch and instead use it as one tool in a broader strategy that prioritizes authentic storytelling and controlled messaging. This isn’t about throwing out the baby with the bathwater; it’s about finding a balance that allows for genuine customer engagement while maintaining brand integrity.
1. Create Branded UGC Campaigns: Just because you’re taking back control doesn’t mean abandoning UGC altogether. Instead, guide your audience on the type of content you’d like them to share. Run campaigns that encourage specific types of user content that align with your brand’s values and aesthetics. For example, ask customers to share moments of joy with your product in everyday settings, but give them creative freedom to make it personal and real.
2. Invest in Professional Content that Feels Personal: Just because content is professionally produced doesn’t mean it can’t feel authentic. Work with photographers and videographers who specialize in capturing real moments in a polished way. This content can then be interspersed with UGC to create a balanced mix of controlled, high-quality visuals and authentic user content.
3. Tell Your Brand’s Story Directly: Step up your game by creating content that tells your brand’s story through your own lens. This could be through behind-the-scenes videos, interviews with your team, or showcasing the craftsmanship behind your products. When your audience sees the real people behind the brand, it builds trust and creates a deeper connection.
Balancing professional content with UGC and direct storytelling can maintain authenticity while keeping your brand’s messaging on point.
Moving Beyond UGC: Strategies to Build Genuine Connections
UGC isn’t the only way to build a connection with your audience. Brands need to diversify their content strategies to include more direct interactions and storytelling.
Engage with Your Audience Directly: Go beyond reposting UGC by actively engaging with your audience. Comment on their posts, ask questions, and get involved in conversations. Make them feel seen and heard—not just as a tool for your marketing but as valued members of your community.
Leverage Micro-Influencers: Big-name influencers are great for reach, but micro-influencers often bring more genuine engagement. These smaller influencers usually have a closer relationship with their followers and can provide more authentic content that resonates better with their audience.
Host Events or Interactive Campaigns: Take things offline (or to more interactive online platforms). Host live events, webinars, or Q&A sessions that allow your audience to interact directly with your brand. This kind of engagement builds real connections and makes your audience feel like they’re part of something special.
Diversifying your content strategy with direct engagement and micro-influencer partnerships can create more genuine connections with your audience.
Looking Forward: UGC as Part of a Bigger Picture
The goal isn’t to ditch UGC entirely but to use it wisely as part of a well-rounded content strategy. By combining UGC with professional content and direct brand storytelling, you can maintain control over your brand’s image while still benefiting from the authenticity that UGC provides.
Think of UGC as the garnish, not the main course. It adds flavor and variety but shouldn’t overshadow the carefully crafted story your brand is telling. It’s about using UGC to complement your content strategy, not define it.
Highlight: UGC should complement your brand’s content strategy, not define it—use it as a part of a balanced approach.
Finding the Balance
UGC had its moment, but like all trends, it’s evolving. For brands looking to maintain their authenticity while controlling their message, it’s time to rethink the strategy. Balance is key. Use UGC, but don’t rely on it. Invest in professional, personal content, and engage directly with your audience. That’s how you create a brand narrative that feels real, relevant, and, most importantly, yours.
---
Raised Media Co. is a NYC-based commercial photography and video production agency specializing in experiential visual content. We help brands and personalities tell compelling stories through high-impact photos and videos.
Comments